Why Do I Feel Guilty When I Set Boundaries?

You told someone you couldn't do something.

You didn't raise your voice. You didn't make an accusation. You gave a reasonable answer to a request.

They replied, “Okay.”

Now you're looking at that message, trying to figure out what they meant.

Were they upset? Did you sound rude? Should you explain why you said no? Maybe you should send another message so they know you're not angry with them.

You start typing.

What makes this interesting is that nothing has actually happened to suggest you made the wrong decision. The other person accepted your answer. But your mind is still working on how to make sure they're okay with it.

Why saying no can feel like doing something wrong

When people talk about boundaries, they often focus on what to say.

How do I tell someone no? What words should I use? How do I communicate my needs?

Those are useful questions. But for some people, the hardest part comes after they've already communicated the boundary.

They can say no. They just struggle to leave it there.

If you've spent years paying attention to other people's reactions, you may have learned to treat someone's disappointment as a sign that you need to do something.

Maybe you grew up in an environment where keeping the peace meant anticipating what other people needed. Maybe disagreement led to criticism, conflict, or withdrawal. Or maybe you've simply become the person everyone counts on to make things work.

Over time, you can develop a rule that sounds something like this:

If someone is unhappy with my decision, I need to make it better.

That rule can follow you into adult relationships, even when the circumstances are very different.

The difference between guilt and responsibility

Guilt can be useful when you've actually done something that conflicts with your values.

But feeling guilty doesn't automatically mean you've done something wrong.

Consider the difference between these two situations.

You agreed to help someone, forgot about your commitment, and left them without notice.

Or you were asked to help, looked at your existing responsibilities, and said you weren't available.

Both situations might leave you feeling guilty. They don't involve the same responsibility.

In the second situation, someone may still be disappointed. They may have to change their plans or ask somebody else.

You can care about that without deciding you were wrong to say no.

The work is learning to evaluate your decision based on what actually happened, rather than using someone else's emotional response as the final measure of whether you were allowed to make it.

Why you want to send the second message

Think about what happens after you've set a boundary.

You might reread the conversation. You may start listing reasons your decision was reasonable. You might imagine the other person telling someone else that you were selfish.

Then comes the urge to explain again.

Sometimes additional information really is necessary. But sometimes that second message is an attempt to get rid of the discomfort you're feeling.

You want reassurance that the relationship is okay, that nobody is upset, and that you haven't created a problem.

The trouble is that another explanation may only settle things temporarily.

If the underlying rule remains unchanged, you'll probably find yourself needing reassurance again the next time you disappoint someone.

What to practice after setting a boundary

Start by paying attention to what happens after you've said what you needed to say.

Before sending another explanation, ask yourself what you're hoping it will accomplish.

Did you leave out information the other person genuinely needs? Are you correcting something inaccurate? Or are you trying to make sure they don't feel disappointed?

Those are different reasons to communicate.

You can also examine the rule you're using to judge yourself.

If your rule is that a good friend, partner, parent, or colleague should never inconvenience anyone, almost every boundary will feel like a failure.

But is that a reasonable standard for a relationship?

Would you expect someone you care about to agree to every request you make? Would you assume they didn't care about you because they weren't available?

If not, why are you holding yourself to that expectation?

Then comes the part that often takes practice: allowing the conversation to be finished.

You may still feel uncomfortable. You may still wonder whether the other person is disappointed.

You don't necessarily need to do anything about those feelings.

Boundaries are also about what happens afterward

A boundary isn't only the sentence you say to another person.

It's also what you do when the familiar urge to explain, apologize, check, or change your mind shows up.

You can understand why that urge is there and still choose not to follow it.

That's where the pattern begins to change.

At Resurgence Therapy PLLC, we help adults examine the rules they've developed about responsibility, relationships, and what they're expected to manage. Therapy can help you understand where those rules came from and practice responding differently when they no longer fit your life.

We provide online therapy for adults in Texas and North Carolina.

Learn more: https://www.resurgencetherapy.org

Next
Next

Why Can't I Relax Even When Everything Is Fine?